Retained executive search and contingency headhunting are two ways to pay a headhunter and set up a search in Vietnam: retained search is exclusive and paid in stages for the search work, contingency is paid only when a hire is made. Neither model belongs to a fixed role level. The right choice follows what your search needs: how confidential it is, how hard the right people are to reach, how much assessment you want, and who should carry the risk of no hire.
This guide explains how each model works, compares them side by side, gives four questions that settle the choice for your role, and lists the mistakes that cost you candidates before the search has started. It is part of our guide to headhunting in Vietnam.
TL;DR
Choose the model by what the search needs, not by the job title: retained search when you need exclusivity, a full market map and written assessment; contingency when you want reach and pay-on-hire.
- Retained executive search is an exclusive mandate, paid in stages, that delivers a market map and a shortlist of assessed finalists.
- Contingency headhunting is paid only when the hire happens, is usually non-exclusive, and gives you reach across several agencies at once.
- In Vietnam, where some profiles are held by a small group of people, briefing several contingency agencies on the same niche role means those people are approached more than once, and the search stops being confidential.
- Retained and contingency fees are charged at different moments; current market ranges are in our guide to headhunting fees in Vietnam.
What is retained executive search?
Retained executive search is a headhunting model in which you give one firm an exclusive mandate and pay in stages while the search runs, instead of paying only when someone is hired. The fee buys the search work itself: research, approaches, assessment and a written shortlist report.
In a retained search, the headhunter starts with research rather than a database. It maps the companies and people that match your role, approaches them directly, interviews the interested ones and assesses them against the brief your headquarters signed off. Because the mandate is exclusive, the firm can approach a passive leader once, under your agreed confidentiality rules, without another agency calling the same person the same week.
Retained search is one form of executive search. If you are still deciding whether a role needs executive search at all, our article on executive search vs recruitment explains the difference.
What is contingency headhunting?
Contingency headhunting is a model in which the agency is paid only when your hire is made, usually triggered by the candidate signing the offer or starting work, depending on the contract. Agencies work from their network and database, add targeted outreach, and send you CVs of people who are interested and match the brief.
Contingency mandates are non-exclusive unless you agree otherwise, so you can brief more than one agency on the same role. That spreads your reach for roles with many suitable people, such as an accounting manager or a senior Java developer in Ho Chi Minh City. The trade-off is depth: an agency that is paid only on success puts its time into candidates it can place quickly, not into mapping the whole market. Check in the contract which event triggers payment, because offer signature and start date fall weeks apart under Vietnam’s notice rules.
Retained vs contingency: side-by-side comparison
The main difference between retained executive search and contingency headhunting is who carries the risk of no hire and how deep the search goes.
| Criterion | Retained executive search | Contingency headhunting |
|---|---|---|
| When you pay | In stages during the search | Only when the hire is made |
| Exclusivity | Exclusive to one firm | Usually non-exclusive |
| Search depth | Research-led map of the target market | Network, database and targeted outreach |
| Assessment | Written assessment per finalist | CV, screening notes and interview feedback |
| Confidentiality | One firm approaches each person once | Harder to control across several agencies |
| Role level | Any level; chosen by search needs | Any level; chosen by search needs |
| Risk of no hire | Shared: you pay for the search work | Carried by the agency |
| Fits best when | Profile is scarce, search is confidential or you want written assessment | Many suitable people are visible and you want pay-on-hire |
Which model fits your hire in Vietnam?
The model that fits your hire depends on what the search needs, not on the job title: the same director role can suit contingency in one market and retained search in another. Four questions settle the choice for your role.
What is at stake if the hire goes wrong
The higher the impact of a wrong hire, the more a retained search adds through its research and written assessment. Impact is about what the role decides, not its title: P&L responsibility, acting as legal representative of your Vietnamese entity, or owning a client relationship your business depends on.
A senior role with a clear profile and many suitable people can run well on contingency, with your own team doing the assessment. A specialist role with a scarce skill set can justify a retained search even below management level. Decide on impact and scarcity together.
How visible the right people are in Vietnam
When only a small group of people in Vietnam fits your profile, retained search protects that group from repeated approaches. For example, a Japanese-speaking plant manager with automotive experience in the northern industrial zones may be a profile where you can name the likely candidates in a short list.
With contingency agencies, every firm competes for those same names, and the first agency to call gets the CV, whether or not its approach was well prepared. A retained headhunter can map the group once, approach each person with a consistent message and tell you who declined and why. When the profile is broad and the pool is visible, several contingency agencies add reach without that risk.
Confidentiality of the search
A confidential search belongs with one exclusive headhunter, which in practice means a retained mandate. Typical cases are replacing an incumbent leader who does not know yet, or building a team before you announce your entry into Vietnam.
A simple signal is whether you would post the role publicly. If not, every additional agency is one more party holding your company name and the reason for the search. An exclusive mandate lets you agree in writing how the role is described to candidates and when your company name is revealed.
How much assessment your headquarters needs
When the hiring decision is made at headquarters, far from the Vietnamese market, a written assessment of each finalist gives decision-makers the same view of every candidate. A retained search delivers that report: for example, three assessed finalists, each with two references, compared on the criteria your brief set.
Contingency fits well when your local team runs the interviews and makes the decision from CVs and its own assessment. For what happens after you have chosen a model, from the written brief to the offer, see our guide on how to work with a headhunter.
Not sure whether your role needs a retained search? Tell us the role and level, and our recruitment team will recommend a model and explain how we would run it. See our recruitment services.
How each model runs in practice
Retained executive search and contingency headhunting produce different deliverables, so agree in writing what you will receive before the search starts. The difference shows in what lands on your desk, not in the number of interviews.
What you receive in a retained search
A retained search gives you a market map, an approach log, a shortlist of assessed finalists with references, and support through the offer. The market map lists the companies and people researched; the approach log shows who was contacted, who was interested and who declined.
Each finalist comes with a written assessment against your brief, so your headquarters compares leaders on the same criteria. Agree the number of finalists and the report format at the start. Offer support matters here because senior leaders in Vietnam often receive a counter-offer from their current employer, and the headhunter manages that conversation with the candidate.
What you receive in a contingency search
A contingency search gives you CVs of interested people who match your brief, interview coordination and support through the offer. Your local HR team does the deeper assessment in its own interviews.
When several agencies work the same role, two of them may submit the same person. Agree a rule up front: the first agency to submit a named candidate with the candidate’s consent owns that submission. Keep a dated log of every CV received so that a duplicate does not turn into a fee dispute after the hire.
Whichever model you use, plan the start date around the candidate’s notice period. Under Article 35 of the Labour Code 2019, an employee on an indefinite-term contract must give at least 45 days’ notice before leaving, so a signed offer rarely means a start the following month.
What each model costs
Retained and contingency fees differ mainly in when you pay: during the search for retained, on the hire for contingency. Current market ranges and fee structures are in our guide to headhunting fees in Vietnam.
Mistakes when choosing a headhunting model
The costly mistakes happen when the model does not match the role, or when the contract leaves out what you are paying for. Four mistakes cover who approaches whom, what you pay for, what is agreed and when you change course.
Briefing several agencies on a niche or confidential search
Briefing several contingency agencies on a niche or confidential role means the same people get calls from different firms about your vacancy. In a small pool, perhaps ten or fifteen people for a niche profile, each extra call makes your company look unorganised and puts confidentiality at risk.
The signal is a candidate telling you that another agency already called about this role. If that happens, stop adding agencies and move the role to one exclusive mandate before more names are approached.
Paying a retainer without a defined shortlist deliverable
A retainer without a defined deliverable leaves you paying for activity with no agreed output. Agree in writing what each payment stage buys: the market map, the number of assessed finalists and the format of the assessment report.
The warning signal is that you have no written search plan after the first payment. Ask for the plan, the target company list and the first approach log before the next stage is invoiced.
No agreement on exclusivity and off-limits companies
Before the search starts, agree how long the mandate is exclusive and which companies the headhunter will not approach. Headhunters normally keep their own clients off-limits, and that can remove companies you assumed were in scope.
Ask for the off-limits list in writing at the briefing. If a key competitor is on it, you know early that this headhunter cannot cover your full target market for this role.
Switching models halfway through the search
Moving a stalled contingency role to a retained search does not continue where the agencies stopped; it restarts the market approach. People who were already called by several agencies are less willing to take another call about the same role.
Decide the model at the start, based on scarcity, confidentiality and the assessment you need. If a contingency search stalls because the profile turned out to be scarcer than briefed, rewrite the brief first, then choose one firm.
How Sunbytes helps you choose
The model, the deliverables and the exclusivity terms are all settled before the first candidate is called. Sunbytes helps you decide those three points for your role, then runs the search with the depth it needs.
Our recruitment services add validation where your decision calls for it: role-based assessments, technical tests, specialist interviews or reference checks, summarised so finalists can be compared on the same criteria. Candidate and client information stays within Sunbytes’ ISO 27001-certified information security management system, which matters when the search is confidential.
When your new hire will work in Vietnam before you have a local entity, the same Sunbytes team continues after the offer: our Employer of Record services handle the local employment contract, and our payroll services run the monthly payroll. Behind that sit 15+ years of experience, 300+ projects, work across 20+ countries and a talent pool of 100K+ skilled professionals.
Tell us the role and what the search needs, and we will recommend a model and explain the cost for your case. Talk to our recruitment team.







